Thanksgiving Pies in Nassau County
November is here, and Thanksgiving preparations are in full swing! A perfect feast calls for perfect pies, and Nassau County bakeries have plenty of delectable options. Whether you're looking for classic flavors like apple and pumpkin or something more unique, these bakeries have covered you. Here's a roundup of the best spots for Thanksgiving pies in Nassau County, including their websites, specialties, and must-try pies.
Buttercooky Bakery
📍 Floral Park, NY
🌐 buttercookybakery.com
A Nassau County institution, Buttercooky Bakery is known for its traditional European-style pastries, cookies, and pies. Their dedication to quality and craftsmanship makes every bite a delight.
Must-Try Pie: Pumpkin Chiffon Pie – A light and fluffy twist on a classic Thanksgiving favorite.
Cardinali Bakery
📍 Carle Place, NY
🌐 cardinalibakery.com
Cardinali Bakery is renowned for its Italian-inspired desserts and freshly baked goods. The friendly atmosphere and wide selection of treats make it a must-visit for holiday desserts.
Must-Try Pie: Tiramisu Pie – A unique blend of Italian tradition and Thanksgiving indulgence.
Dortoni Bakery & Café
📍 Levittown, NY
🌐 dortonibakery.com
Dortoni Bakery has been serving gourmet Italian pastries and desserts for decades. Their pies are as delightful as their cakes, and there are options to suit any Thanksgiving table.
Must-Try Pie: Pecan Pie – Rich and buttery, packed with perfectly caramelized pecans.
Front Street Bakery
📍 Rockville Centre, NY
🌐 frontstreetbakery.com
This family-run bakery is famous for its crumb cakes, but its pies are equally spectacular. Their focus on fresh, homemade-style treats makes every dessert memorable.
Must-Try Pie: Apple Crumb Pie – A perfect balance of spiced apples and a buttery crumb topping.
Malverne Pastry Shop
📍 Malverne, NY
🌐 malvernepastryshop.com
A cozy neighborhood favorite, Malverne Pastry Shop specializes in cupcakes and pies, offering various fresh and flavorful options.
Must-Try Pie: Sweet Potato Pie – A rich, creamy classic with a hint of warm spices.
Marie Blachère Bakery & Café
📍 Great Neck, NY
🌐 marieblachereus.com
Known for its French artisanal baking, Marie Blachère offers exquisite breads, pastries, and pies. The elegant ambiance and high-quality ingredients make this bakery a standout.
Must-Try Pie: French Apple Tart – A sophisticated take on the classic apple pie with a delicate, flaky crust.
Polka Dot Pound Cake
📍 Rockville Centre, NY
🌐 polkadotpoundcake.com
This boutique bakery creates small-batch, homemade-style desserts with a creative twist. Every pie is made with love and high-quality ingredients.
Must-Try Pie: Cranberry Apple Pie – A tart yet sweet combination of fresh fruits with a hint of orange zest.
Sapienza Bake Shop
📍 Elmont, NY
🌐 sapienzabakeshop.com
This third-generation bakery specializes in Italian desserts and various pies. Everything is made on-site with time-tested recipes.
Must-Try Pie: Pignoli Pie is a uniquely Italian treat made with pine nuts and a rich filling.
Sweetie Pies on Main
📍 Cold Spring Harbor, NY
🌐 sweetiepiesonmain.com
Sweetie Pies is a charming coffeehouse and bakery, which is perfect for grabbing a delicious pie and a cozy drink. Their attention to quality and presentation shines through every dessert.
Must-Try Pie: Dark Cherry Pie – A luscious pie loaded with plump, juicy cherries.
Tulip Bake Shop
📍 Floral Park, NY
🌐 tulipbakeshop.com
A beloved local bakery, Tulip Bake Shop is a one-stop shop for cookies, cakes, and pies that feel like home. Their long-standing recipes never disappoint.
Must-Try Pie: German Apple Pie—This hearty, spiced pie has layers of apples and a perfectly crispy crust.
Pro Tip: Many of these bakeries offer limited quantities, so place your orders early to guarantee your Thanksgiving favorites!
Which pie are you picking up this Thanksgiving? Let us know in the comments below! 🥧🍂
