Craving something cold and sweet? From old-school cones to rich gelato and over-the-top rolled creations, Nassau County has no shortage of spots to treat yourself. And with National Ice Cream Day coming up on Sunday, July 20th, there’s no better excuse to check out the best local scoop shops across the North and South Shores.
Check out our picks for the best ice cream in Nassau County, organized by North Shore and South Shore locations—each with a recommended flavor to try. From old-school soda fountains to trendy rolled ice cream, there's a scoop for everyone.
What goes together with ice cream on hot summer days? A jump in the pool! Here is our guide to the best public pools in Nassau County.
🌊 Best Ice Cream in Nassau County: North Shore Favorites
Dolce Gelato (Franklin Square): This bright, modern gelateria serves European-style flavors with a fresh twist. Try This: Limoncello Gelato.
Gelateria Dei Coltelli (Williston Park): Bold, authentic Italian gelato made fresh daily. Try this: Pistachio di Bronte Gelato.
Hershey's Ice Cream & More (Levittown): Enjoy classic Hershey's flavors in a relaxed, family-friendly setting. Try This: Cappuccino Crunch Sundae.
Hicksville Sweet Shop (Hicksville): A charming retro shop with handmade scoops and soda fountain charm. Try This: Old-Fashioned Chocolate Chip Scoop.
Manny's Sweet Treats (Mineola): Colorful, candy-covered creations perfect for families and foodies. Try This: Cookie Dough Explosion Sundae.
Smusht (Port Washington): Design your cookie + ice cream sandwich. Try This: Make Your Own DIY Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich.
Sugar Bae Café (Hicksville): A fusion dessert café with unique flavors and rich textures. Try This: Gulab Jamun Ice Cream.
Sweet Charlie's (New Hyde Park): Rolled ice cream made right in front of you. Try This: Nutella & Strawberry Roll.
Sweet Treats On the Wharf (Port Washington): A waterfront gem offering creamy, small-batch scoops. Try This: S'mores Sundae.
Van Leeuwen (Roslyn): French-style artisanal ice cream made with simple, quality ingredients. Try This: Honeycomb Ice Cream.
🌴 Best Ice Cream in Nassau County: South Shore Spots
Frozen Cow Ices & Cream (Lido Beach): Popular post-beach stop with soft serve and Italian ices. Try This: Cookie Dough Soft Serve.
Itgen's Ice Cream (Valley Stream): An authentic soda fountain experience with homemade whipped cream. Try This: Butterscotch Sundae.
Krisch's (Massapequa): A Nassau County icon offering massive sundaes and retro vibes. Try This: Banana Split with Homemade Chocolate Sauce.
Lengo's Ice Cream World (Merrick): A cozy shop offering nostalgic flavors and sundaes. Try This: Vanilla Sundae with Walnuts & Whipped Cream.
Let's Roll! (Merrick)Creative rolled ice cream made to order. Try This: Toasted Marshmallow Roll.
Marshall's Ice Cream Bar (Massapequa): A walk-up window with bold scoops and chocolate-forward flavors. Try This: Double Chocolate Chip Cone.
Marvel Frozen Dairy (Lido Beach): A beach staple serving soft serve with flair. Try This: Vanilla-Chocolate Twist Soft Serve.
Nana's Ice Cream & Coffee House (Westbury): A relaxing café-style shop with coffee and cones. Try This: Red Velvet Ice Cream.
Once Upon A Sundae (Rockville Centre): Whimsical, allergy-aware scoops in a kid-friendly space. Try This: Vanilla Bean Ice Cream.
Scoops & Cones II (Farmingdale): Clean and fun with plenty of unique flavors. Try This: Cotton Candy Scoop.
Skipperdee's L'il Ice Cream Shop (Point Lookout): A bright, beachy shop with classic favorites. Try This: Mint Chip in a Waffle Cone.
Sweet Spot Café (Seaford): Generous portions and familiar favorites. Try This: Peanut Butter Cup Sundae.
The Milk & Sugar Truck (Roaming): Dessert truck serving over-the-top sundaes and cookie combos. Try This: Cinnamon Toast Crunch Ice Cream Sandwich.
Van Leeuwen (Garden City): Luxe flavors in a cool, modern shop. Try This: Earl Grey Tea Ice Cream.
What's 4 Dessert? (Freeport) Friendly staff and crowd-pleasing sundaes. Try This: Strawberry Shortcake Sundae.
Celebrate the Best Ice Cream in Nassau County This Summer
Now you know exactly where to find the best ice cream in Nassau County—from timeless soda fountains to innovative dessert trucks. Whether you're on the North Shore or South Shore, you're only a scoop away from your next summer favorite.
📸 Don't forget to tag @YourNorthShoreLiving when you visit one of these fantastic local shops for National Ice Cream Day
